Has this experiment been replicated or verified? 1. [11], Scientists who have reviewed What the Bleep Do We Know!? The Christian Science Monitor has expired. Seven Times Planet TV Studios Went Way Too Far - Rendicin de Cuentas Check out this great listen on Audible.com. Gifted and talented kids: how do you nurture a curious mind. But when you hear about quantum mechanics and consciousness, you should assume the author is a crackpot unless proven otherwise. What the Bleep Do We Know? | Not Even Wrong - Columbia University While Amanda waits for a commuter train, she (and we) are shown the work of Japanese scientist Masaru Emoto, who has photographed water after exposing it to different emotions. The film surpassed all expectations; it was certainly the stupidest thing I can remember seeing in a movie theater, and thats saying quite a lot (I see a lot of movies). Water beamed messages of love or gratitude formed itself into lovely snowflake-like crystals; water exposed to the words "You make me sick" looks like the surface of a toxic waste pond. They are relevant because of the deliberateness on the part of the film makers to keep certain facts unknown (ironically, it is I making the unknown know) and misrepresent others. In reality, science is completely incidental to the film's conclusions. It comes from the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, and it's about the limitations of trying to measure the position and momentum of subatomic particles this only applies to sub-atomic particlesa rock doesn't need you to bump into it to exist. In addition to the films three directors, there were actors and others involved in the production who are long time "students" of Ramthas' School of enlightenment. If you wanted to study the impact of spoken, drawn or written sentiments on the formation of crystals in freezing water, you'd have to do a slightly more rigorous study. and published a study guide. The following persons in the film have all spoken at RSE and sold books there. Marlee Matlin, Barry Newman, Elaine Hendrix. A moment in which 'the mathematical formalisms of quantum mechanics [] are stripped of all empirical content and reduced to a set of syrupy nostrums'. So does classical physics. "The movie is saying that somehow we can all get together and, with our collective thought processes, we can influence the outcome" of physical events - be they life experiences or scientific. We're not using either superconductivity or superfluidity yet on the scale that I think people thought we might. By continuing to browse the site What the bleep do we know debunked Isn't life great? Isnt Langs viewpoint in line with the sort of criticism that string theory receives at this web site? But we behave like classical objects for a reason: We're big, we have lots of particles, they interact. What the #$*! Do We (K)now!? - Letterboxd Intercut with these metaphysical ponderings is a soapy fictional narrative starring Marlee Matlin as a broken-hearted photographer. Skeptic James Randi described the film as "a fantasy docudrama" and "[a] rampant example of abuse by charlatans and cults". Photos View All Photos Movie Info Amanda, a divorced photographer, has a fantastic experience when life begins to unravel around her, revealing the cellular,. you are agreeing to our, One month free trial to theMonitorDaily, Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor, Performance of quantum computer no better than ordinary PC, say analysts, 'Spooky' physics: How quantum entanglement could link wormholes, Quantum 'teleportation' distance record broken. [5], According to the makers of the film, "Bleep" is an expurgation of "fuck". The web makes all such things available today, so I can give you a Google link to a page about Maharishis unified field theory, http://www.worldpeaceendowment.org/invincibility/invincibility6.html. We want to bridge divides to reach everyone. In the 1970s that abruptly stopped and moved to getting us off this planet. You are free to comment as you wish. There was some sort of plot involving a woman photographer (played by Marlee Matlin), who wanders around and has anxiety attacks. We're such a shallow people. Interviews with scientists and authors, animated bits, and a storyline involving a deaf photographer are used in this docudrama to illustrate the link between quantum mechanics, neurobiology, human consciousness and day-to-day reality. I want to mention another point Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. He also has been marketing several products within the school and its followers. What The Bleep!? Down The Rabbit Hole | Documentary Heaven "[15], Bernie Hobbs, a science writer with ABC Science Online, explains why the film is incorrect about quantum physics and reality: "The observer effect of quantum physics isn't about people or reality. ISHEAGU MASSACRE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND: Isheagu is a town whose origin is traceable to the Eastern part of the contraption called Nigeria. We're bombarded by many things every second of the day, and a result, we're not specially prepared quantum mechanical systems, nor can we exert weird quantum powers over other objects. It was one of the most important moments in history. 3) Lots of people still hunger for a magical universe, and now hope that science can deliver it, after Nietsche's announcement of God's death. In the film, during a discussion of the influence of experience on perception, Candace Pert notes a story, which she says she believes is true, of Native Americans being unable to see Columbus's ships because they were outside their experience. is god-awful. And you'd do the study without knowing what had been 'said' to the water specimens, so your subjective opinions wouldn't colour the results. What the #$*! Author, speaker, and award-winning Writer/Director/Producer Mark Vicente was part of the creative team behind the sleeper hit "What The Bleep Do We Know?!". "But that's two leaps beyond what scientists believe to be true.". He claims that in over 5 hours of interviews he explained to the film makers why their concept of how Quantum Physics works has virtually no support in the scientific community. Review of the What the Bleep Do We Know? - Christian Research Institute Once they do bump into each other they form their regular little selves. Watch What The Bleep Do We Know?! | Prime Video - amazon.com If COVID-19 mRNA is safe where are the libel lawsuits by Pharma? Moreover, assume that they want your money. Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. [4] The visual-effects team, led by Evan Jacobs, worked closely with the other film-makers to create visual metaphors that would capture the essence of the film's technical subjects with attention to aesthetic detail. The debate here is that we'll be able to use quantum mechanics to break codes, in particular to determine the big prime numbers that are at the basis of the security of your credit cards and your bank cards. But she is right about us not seeing things in front of our eyes if we're not looking for them. Amanda is a divorced woman who makes a living as a photographer. 4. Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Down the Rabbit Hole. "What The Bleep Do We Know? [4], Lacking the funding and resources of the typical Hollywood film, the filmmakers relied on "guerrilla marketing" first to get the film into theaters, and then to attract audiences. People latch onto their dreams, and they always try to match them to reality. What The Bleep Do We Know DEBUNKED., page 2 Now comes the audio edition of the book based on the mind-boggling movie that grossed $11 million in the U.S. alone. asks nothing but . Details in the video itself.EXTENDED REFERENCES:Revelation:[a] Michael Freze, 1993, Voices, Visions, and Apparitions, OSV Publishing ISBN 087973454X page 252[b] http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/faith[c] http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=confidence[d] http://www.thefreedictionary.com/faith[e] http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/faith[f] Dictionary.com. Update: More information at the end of the video description.Comment approval now removed. Next factoid: Crime in Washington, D.C. was reduced 25 percent by prayer--and made believers of the D.C. cops! They were spreading their methods of meditation but that was not the main thing that impressed me. After a lesson in quantum mechanics from a precocious kid on a . 5.Miceal Ledwith a clergyman with a rather dubious past (see http://unison.ie/irish_independent/stories.php3?ca=36&si=770458&issue_id=7565) is the one chosen by the film makers to be the theological spokesman. was heavily criticised for being "a documentary aimed at the totally gullible". That's why we experience a classical world. "What the bleep. Now I don't have an automatic prejudice against 35,000-year-old warriors from Atlantis or the women who channel them. Neither of them convincingly achieve this. You can't change the world by thinking about it. There were many more, but I will leave them for others. You can be accurate in one or the other, but not in both. Down the Rabbit Hole - Quantum Edition multi-disc DVD set was released, containing two extended versions of What the Bleep Do We Know! "What the Bleep" begins in NOVA-like fashion: galaxies swirl and scientists--we aren't told who they are until the end--expound on quantum mechanics and the nature of the universe. "The theory can't predict with precision what will happen, but it knows everything that can happen and it will tell you the probability of all these things happening.". While many of its interviewees and subjects are professional scientists in the fields of physics, chemistry, and biology, one of them has noted that the film quotes him out of context. (I haven't). We'd like to be able to influence things just by thinking about them, we'd like to transport ourselves elsewhere without getting on an airplane. the film What The Bleep Do We Know It was an information that really left me speechless and I ordered his books at once techhose.d-webhost.orphans.co.uk 2 / 11. By clicking 'Send to a friend' you agree ABC Online is not responsible for the content contained in your email message. Viewers instead are fed a nauseating stream of nonsense that traces back to the teaching of a woman who claims to channel a 35,000-year-old deity. That matter is not solid, and electrons are able to pop in and out of existence without it being known where they disappear to. The quantum world is intriguing, but unless you're a particle physicist it's got very little to do with the world's reality. Its true that Hagelin stopped doing physics in the mid-nineties to concentrate on his other nonsense, but I can vouch for the fact that as early as 1978-9 he was heavily involved in TM and thought it had a lot to do with QFT. A: Absolutely. : Directed by William Arntz, Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente. Producing, scripting, and co-directing the film, What the BLEEP went on to become a global phenomenon, with well over 100 million viewers experiencing the BLEEP. We use it to assign probabilities to possible measurement outcomes on the basis of actual measurement outcomes. 16 Quotes From the Movies ideas - Pinterest What the Bleep!? Despite his caveats, he recommends that people see the film, stating: "I hope it develops into a cult movie in the UK as it has in the US. (commonly referred to by its spoken title What the Bleep Do We Know) is a 2004 pseudoscientific film that supports the idea that consciousness and quantum mechanics are somehow related. Featured individuals [ edit] The film features interview segments of: For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. The question is, how far down the rabbit hole, do you wanna go? continue to use the site without a Hard to get your head around What the Bleep Do We Know. Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. The quantum mechanical correlations, the spooky action at a distance that quantum mechanics brings up, is true only for very specially prepared systems that are isolated from the rest of the world, completely. It is just a movie. His 73 papers are mostly about supersymmetric GUTs and considered quite respectable, with a total of over 5000 citations, including 641 citations for one of them alone. Lawrence Krauss: I think it's probably one of the most abused concepts in physics among the public. Professor Clive Greated wrote that "thinking on neurology and addiction are covered in some detail but, unfortunately, early references in the film to quantum physics are not followed through, leading to a confused message". Daniel Monti, physician and director of the Mind-Body Medicine Program at. so much for no good or bad, that is unless it is convienent. And if you really want to be friendly, ask me about "The Case forPluto.". They want suggestions, not formulas. You can't just hope for the best. [5] Author Barrie Dolnick adds that "people don't want to learn how to do one thing. As the Amanda plot zooms here and there, a host of dubious evidence is marshaled to convince us that life is all about mind over matter. We all know most parts of the ocean are still undiscovered but there's plenty of theories. ( ) - What the bleep Do we know Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Pingback: Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, Pingback: For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. People tend to believe that the fact that a certain kind of research is pursued by sizable numbers of people with very good credentials is enough to mean it must be good research. 2. Around 650 million people watched the moment on television. Those points suggest that quantum-derived "possibilities" affect the wider world, that human thought is the ultimate arbiter of physical reality, and that by manipulating thought properly, people can achieve harmony and even shape the structure of matter. ", "What the Bleep Do We Know!? Filmed to promote a new age philosophy based on a very, very broad interpretation of quantum physics, the movie was funded by J. improve functionality and performance. For many years in the early-mid-eighties, the Maharishi was pushing N=8 supergravity as the unified field theory, I remember a colorful poster explaining how it agreed exactly with his philosophy that many people posted on their walls. Matt, what is so nutty about Serge Langs ideas about HIV and AIDS? It's certainly not. Thorough debunking of that shlock "What The Bleep Do We Know?" - Yelp Q. . Pingback: yeago works Blog Archive Jesus, Buddha, Ken Wilber?? What the Bleep Do We Know?: Discovering the Endless Possibilities for I mean listen, you have very reputable individuals who believe in validation, as experimental proof. What the #$*! Do We Know!? (Film) - TV Tropes logged you out. The question "What the bleep do we know?" has an unambiguous answer: both surprisingly much and amazingly little. What the 'Bleep'!?:Down The Rabbit Hole - DVD Talk Evidently Albert claims he was taken advantage of, that his interview was heavily edited to misrepresent his views. "I create my own reality, says quantum physics," intones one expert, and the viewer could be lured to accept this as proof. Check my single page unpublishable http://dftuz.unizar.es/~rivero/research/simple.pdf. Well, people are able to undergo various transformations. Your session to The Christian Unfortunately hes written no papers after 1995, see, http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/find/hep/www?rawcmd=find+a+hagelin&FORMAT=WWW&SEQUENCE=. I suggest to read him if you want to know how QM is perceived in the SF community. It's more like a collision in the editing room between talking heads, an impenetrable human parable and a hallucinogenic animated cartoon. Science and engineering are important for our future, and anything that engages the public can only be a good thing." The reason you should be suspicious is because we don't even understand classical consciousness. [19], According to Margaret Wertheim, "History abounds with religious enthusiasts who have read spiritual portent into the arrangement of the planets, the vacuum of space, electromagnetic waves and the big bang. What the Bleep Do We Know!? | Bleep 2 - The Prodigal Movie Prominent if you go by citations that is. On the other hand, one finds 3+1, or more concretely inverse square law, to be mathematically peculiar when it refers to gravity, ie when mass is the source of the force. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); WatchDocumentaries.com | Games | Quizzes | Contact |Privacy & Terms | Manage Cookies |Advertise | DMCA, Aleister Crowley: The Wickedest Man in the World. The 2004 theatrical release was succeeded by a substantially changed, extended home media version in 2006. If it were manifest, you could run at a wall a lot of times, and every now and then you'd spontaneously appear on the other side of the wall. Whether you're religious, spiritual, or none of the above, you can say one thing for this movie: it's an equal-opportunity offender. Blech. Particles are fluctuations the rules of physics say it's perfectly fine for them to exist at some time and/or place and to be non-existent at another time and/or place. She works as a free-lancer for an agency, where her boss is played by Barry Newman. Remembering The Isheagu Massacre Of May 1968 - Politics - Nigeria It's there. This website uses cookies to If anyone has any information to refute any of the facts laid out here, I will be more then willing to retract them. Even though there's lots of proof that the Moon landing happened, some people don't . The Bleep in a Nutshell: 1. Everyone said that you have to see this movie! So I did. List of films featuring the deaf and hard of hearing, "How the NXIVM Sex Cult Defended Trump from Media Attacks", "Cinefex article detailing the visual effects for the film", "New Age: What the Bleep? " !" | (1080p I was really impressed and although it sounded totally crazy, the Einsteinian language that their brochures were using had nearly convinced me that they really know something about fundamental physics. The host of the show said this was done because it was negative Down the Rabbit Hole - Quantum Edition multi-disc DVD set was released, containing two extended versions of What the Bleep Do We Know! Unfortunately, it also completely misunderstands it. But this only applies to sub-atomic particles a rock doesn't need you to bump into it to exist. With Alejandro Jodorowsky, Horacio Salinas, Zamira Saunders, Juan Ferrara. I guess the difference between me and those other people is that I actually have some grasp on the concepts that the movie was trying to talk about. It took a while, but the comparison finally came through on the association of strings, as a quantum mechanical perspective, and the relationship to that movie. It was clearly time to check the facts for myself. The general idea was that since quantum mechanics supposedly says that there isnt one reality, but an infinite number of possibilities, one just has to be enlightened to an awareness of this, and then you can make whatever you want happen. The idea that our own perceptions can't be trusted is not new, of course. you refer to the offspring of hep-ph/9803315. If you have questions about your account, please last of a series of columns written for Scientific American, Why great minds can't grasp consciousness. Amanda is a photographer, who seems to be highly skilled but not very successful professionally. But the movie gradually moves to quantum 'insights' that lead a woman to toss away her antidepressant medication, to the quantum channeling of Ramtha, the 35,000-year-old Lemurian warrior, and on to even greater nonsense." But they add that the film shows quantum mysteries selectively to shore up metaphysical points. Certainly, our attitudes and brain chemistry affect how we see the world and get through life. But to insist, as one on-screen interviewee does, that the material world around us is just one "possible movement of consciousness" undermines the possibility of any objective, external reality--something fundamental to many religions and to science. What the Bleep Do We Know?: Discovering the Endless - Amazon The movie features other proclaimed scientists who . On the whole they were a bunch of complete flakes, although one of them (David Albert) is a philosopher of science here at Columbia. But whenever one is dealing with highly speculative ideas that have no connection with experiment, theres a danger of becoming delusional and thinking that youre doing real science when youre not. But how are ordinary mortals to judge its assertions about the nature of matter, mind, and the universe? So you forgive the film's jelly-baby graphics, daggy storyline, and that Gabor sister channelling a warrior spirit from Atlantis. At some point I guess he updated it to string field theory and the version you provided a link for. The film "What the Bleep Do We Know?!" [12][13] Lisa Randall refers to the film as "the bane of scientists". A disproportionate amount of time was given in voice and film to Ramtha, Dr. Joe dispenza, and Miceal Ledwith. Z. Knight and heavily features commentary from 'Ramtha', an ancient Atlantian general who is apparently speaking through Knight. Having watched this travesty of a movie, any real scientist worth his quarks might be gun-shy about joining the debate. Joe Dispenza The pity of it is that there are fascinating conversations going on in the science-and-religion sphere. It is my task to convince you not to turn away because you don't understand it. The narrative follows a fictional photographer, Amanda, through her emotional and existential journey of life. Categories conflate, confound, connect", "Our power is in our ability to decide - Can you? "Our brain receives 400 billion bits/second of information, but we're only aware of 2000 bits/second. 2004 ( ) ( ) Offline 2013. And while I dont think supersymmetric GUTs are anywhere near as promising as many people seem to think, they are a much saner idea than many that dominate research these days (take the Landscape, please). Supported by groups like the Templeton Foundation, legitimateor more creative scientists are exploring the mind-body connection, or the similarities between particle-and-wave physics and certain religious concepts like the Trinity. So thanks to Associate Professor Zdenka Kuncik, Professor Peter Schofield and Professor Max Coltheart for shedding some light on the Bleeping thing. I think of what Niels Bohr said to Wolfgang Pauli about theories that are "not crazy enough to be true." Wertheim continues that the film "abandons itself entirely to the ecstasies of quantum mysticism, finding in this aleatory description of nature the key to spiritual transformation. Dr. Jeffrey Satinover (psychiatrist, PhD candidate in physics), in What the Bleep Do We Know? If I didnt know any better, I would have thought it was something straight out of a Cheech and Chong movie. Invariably only about half the people tested ever notice a woman in a gorilla suit walking across the middle of the screen during the game. 3. Nobody does.". Dr Candice Pert They may applaud the central tenets of the movie, but not its disjointed narrative, clunky acting, bizarre thematic segues, and faux "facts." Can the weirdness of quantum mechanics make you well, or make you wealthy? With quantum mechanics, there's a notion that observers affect the things that they're observing. 3. "What the Bleep Do We Know," as it is referred to for convenience, is not a conventional documentary about quantum physics. He has however just released his third book of pretty crystal pictures. If he says hes being misrepresented, I quite believe him. Hidden Messages In Water Hidden Messages in . . The movie "What the Bleep do we know" How much is true, or just entertainment. Also, the movie suggests that the quantum idea of matter embracing all its possible states at once applies to the larger world of people and rocks. Featuring interviews with scientists and theologians, this compelling film thrusts the viewer into a world where science and spirituality intersect. : Down the Rabbit Hole: Directed by William Arntz, Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente. Ramtha - JZ Knight - The Skeptic's Dictionary - Skepdic.com Then we segue to a narrative starring Amanda (Marlee Maitlin), a wedding photographer who's bummed because her slimy husband cheated on her.